Monsanto vs. organic and non-GMO
farmers as Supreme Court justices probe legal issues surrounding approval
of GM crops.
On April 27, the
fight over genetically modified Roundup Ready alfalfa reached the US
Supreme Court. On one side was the Center for Food Safety (CFS) and
Geertson Seed Farms backed by organic farmers and food companies, environmental
groups, rice farmers, and attorneys general from three states, among
others. On the other side was biotech giant Monsanto backed by farm
groups and diverse trade associations.
The case, Monsanto
vs. Geertson Seed Farms, 09-475. is the first case involving GM crops
that had ever been heard by the Supreme Court.
Monsanto
appeals to Supreme Court
In the initial 2006
court case, CFS and other plaintiffs sued the US Department of Agriculture
(USDA), saying the agency should never have approved GM alfalfa due
to the threat of contamination to organic and non-GMO alfalfa. In 2007,
the US District Court for the Northern District of California ruled
in CFS’s favor, and ordered USDA to conduct an Environmental Impact
Statement (EIS). The court then issued an injunction banning future
sales of GM alfalfa seed until the EIS was completed.
Monsanto intervened
in the case on behalf of USDA, saying the court should not have issued
the injunction stopping plantings of GM alfalfa, which is engineered
to withstand sprays of the company"s Roundup herbicide. Monsanto lost
two appeals in lower courts and then appealed it to the Supreme Court.
Focus on judge"s
authority vs. USDA
During the Supreme
Court hearing on April 27, attorneys for Monsanto, USDA, and CFS presented
their arguments and were sharply questioned by Supreme Court Justices.
Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg told Monsanto’s attorney Gregory Garre
that USDA’s Animal and Plant Health Inspection Service violated federal
law by approving GM alfalfa before completing the Environmental Impact
Statement. Justice Antonin Scalia questioned CFS’s attorney Lawrence
Robbins about the contamination threat.
"This isn"t
contamination of the New York City water supply. The most it does is
make it difficult for those farmers who want to cater to the European
market, which will not accept genetically engineered alfalfa, it makes
it more difficult for them to have a field of 100 percent non-genetically
engineered. But that"s not the end of the world," Scalia said.
While GMO contamination
is a major issue, the Supreme Court focused mainly on whether the judge
in the original case had the authority to order the injunction and whether
he should have sent the issue back to the USDA for the agency to handle.
Chief Justice Roberts
raised that point. "It’s very odd to get an injunction to an agency
telling them they can’t do something under the (Administrative Procedures
Act)," Roberts said. He later said that "The court is stepping into
the shoes of the agency."
Justice Sonia Sotomayor
was more skeptical, asking Monsanto’s attorney Gregory Garre: "So
how can we say that the district court acted improperly, when it"s
the government who is asking the district court to forgive it from doing
something it’s legally required to do (conduct the EIS)?"
A recent editorial
in Capital Press, an Oregon-based agricultural journal, said
that USDA should conduct an EIS for each GM crop. "It would make sense
for APHIS to perform the more rigorous review as a matter of course."
Battle
lines drawn
A myriad of interests, ranging
from food companies to farmers unions to scientific experts and legal
scholars"filed briefs to the Supreme Court in support of the Center
for Food Safety. The Attorneys General of California, Oregon and Massachusetts
filed a brief on behalf of their citizens supporting CFS, noting "immense"
ramifications for all environmental protection should Monsanto prevail.
Leading organic
businesses and trade groups, including Organic Valley, Stonyfield Farms,
the Organic Trade Association, United Natural Foods, Eden Foods, Annie’s,
Clif Bar and Nature’s Path Foods, warned of the imminent threat from
unwanted GMO contamination to their businesses.
The Arkansas Rice
Growers filed a brief stating "Genetically engineered crops have already
contaminated conventional crops, resulting in damages of over a billion
dollars to the rice trade…"
Supporting Monsanto
in the case were 18 groups including American Farm Bureau Federation,
Biotechnology Industry Organization, American Seed Trade Association,
American Soybean Association, National Alfalfa and Forage Alliance,
National Association of Wheat Growers, National Cotton Council, Sugarbeet
Growers Association, National Corn Growers Association, and the US Chamber
of Commerce.
Center for Food
Safety staff attorney George Kimbrell was pleased with the hearing.
"We believe that the Supreme Court argument went well for us. Our
legal team did a great job, in a challenging environment. We think our
arguments hit home with at least some of the Justices. We definitely
have a fighting chance."
The Supreme Court
is expected to issue a ruling on the case in June or July.
(Sources: Capital Press, Environmental
News Service)
© Copyright
June 2010, The Organic & Non-GMO Report