One of the problems
with genetically modified crops is that they create unintended consequences.
Scientists cannot foresee how a GM plant will interact once it is in
a complex ecosystem. A case in point: A new study published in the journal
Science says that the use of GM cotton in China has led to a widespread
increase of another insect pest that is damaging cotton and other crops.
Chinese farmers
have been planting GM cotton, which is engineered to contain the Bt
bacterium that kills bollworm, since 1997. Today more than 4 million
hectares (9.8 million acres) of GM cotton are grown in China.
Since GM cotton
was approved, a team led by Kongming Wu, an entomologist at the Chinese
Academy of Agricultural Sciences in Beijing, has monitored pest populations
in cotton fields. Wu and his team have found that numbers of mirid bugs,
which were previously only a minor pest in northern China, have increased
12-fold since 1997.
"Entire swathes
of agricultural land that never had any problem with this pest are facing
a major problem," says Wu. "Their rise in abundance is associated
with the scale of Bt cotton cultivation.
The increase in
mirids is forcing Chinese farmers back to using more pesticides. They
are currently using about two-thirds as much as they did before Bt cotton
was introduced. As mirids develop resistance to the pesticides, Wu says
the farmers will soon spray as much as they ever did.
Two years ago, a
study led by David Just, an economist at Cornell University found that
the economic benefits of Bt cotton in China had eroded due to increased
pesticide use on secondary pests.
Wu’s findings
confirm Just’s study, says David Andow, an entomologist at the University
of Minnesota in St Paul.
"The finding reminds
us yet again that genetically modified crops are not a magic bullet
for pest control," Andow says. "They have to be part of an integrated
pest-management system to retain long-term benefits."
Environmental groups
seized on the study as further evidence that GM crops are not benefitting
the environment as biotech companies have claimed.
"This is a massive
issue in terms of the environment, but also in terms of costs for the
farmer. The plan with GM crops was to reduce costs and environmental
impact, but neither of these things seem to be happening," said Kirtana
Chandrasekaran, a food campaigner at Friends of the Earth.
(Source: The Guardian, UK)
© Copyright
June 2010
, The Organic & Non-GMO Report