By Jochen Koester
With its policy in the Roundtable for Responsible Soy (RTRS), the
World Wildlife Fund (WWF) has incurred resentment and criticism from
around the world, not only from other non-governmental organizations
(NGOs), but also from partners in trade and industry who have worked
for years on sustainable soy certification. The principles of the RTRS
were recently passed�with the non-GMO issue excluded.
Undoubtedly, NGOs
are important in civil society, and in democratic countries they exercise
significant influence. This is good and even political opponents would
not seriously want to restrict this right. Almost all rights, however,
go hand in hand with responsibilities. This is even more so if the holder
of a right has made any promises or enjoys a particularly high reputation.
WWF calls RTRS �technology neutral�
At the moment, responsibility
shows on the agenda of many NGOs�more or less voluntarily: within
the RTRS the WWF gets involved with Big Business. That in itself is
not objectionable. However, the question arises whether the WWF presents
itself as a responsibly acting partner. For, as was decided in late
May by the RTRS General Assembly in Brazil, non-GMO production is not
part of the principles and criteria of a responsible soybean production.
By pointing out that the RTRS is �technology neutral,�
the WWF has cleared the entire GMO
issue off the table�incurring the wrath of other NGOs.
Basel Criteria
As early as March
2004, WWF Switzerland had undertaken the laudable step together with
the Swiss retailer Coop to launch the Basel Criteria for Responsible
Soy Production. The two organizations wanted to counter the destruction
of the Brazilian rainforest and other conservation areas. Besides environmental,
social and legal demands, the Basel Criteria call for a
production without GMOs�to protect biodiversity. Also, to the vast
majority of Europeans, as well as many other nations, not growing genetically
modified crops is a central pillar of sustainability.
Two certifiers
used the Basel Criteria as the base for their own industry standards;
one certifier has certified tons of Brazil�s soybean harvest
each year since 2006 according to its ProTerra
standard.
First shipments of sustainably produced�and non-GMO�soy
In June 2006, WWF
Switzerland and Coop promoted the fact
that a major Swiss importer received the first 1,200 tons of ProTerra-certified
soy meal shipped to Europe. In July, the
WWF published a statement announcing that both industry standards had
been found compliant with the Basel Criteria, although one of them,
for omission of the non-GMO requirement, would not be compatible with
�Basel.�
One would
assume that WWF and all parties involved would be
happy that a sustainability standard is
successfully implemented and would be
eager to see a growing number of suppliers and buyers in this market.
Roundtable for Responsible Soy
Unfortunately this
is not the case. The WWF is reviewing its principles and
processes, such as the multi-stakeholder process, the roundtable, etc.
And why should one consider a preference for non-GMO food production
that has been expressed by three quarters of the European population?
The Basel Criteria for Responsible Soy Production had been commissioned
with funding from WWF and Coop and
also with Swiss taxpayers� money. On 38 pages, they deliver a brilliant
guidance, based on which two industry standards are set up in the subsequent
years. This, in turn, leads to the year 2009
where over 15% of the total Brazilian soy crop is certified non-GMO
to a standard compliant with the Basel Criteria and shipped to buyers
in Europe.
Despite this, the
WWF supports and promotes the Roundtable for Responsible Soy, founded
in late 2004 in London and has now grown with the joining of major agribusiness
companies, such as ADM, Bunge, Cargill, Monsanto, Syngenta, as well
as with the energy players BP and Shell.
WWF
secrecy is the problem
It is
not the WWF�s involvement in the
RTRS that is irritating! It is the organization�s secrecy
regarding a smoothly and very successfully
functioning platform that was launched by
the WWF itself only a few years before. WWF is acting irresponsibly
not only towards members of the Executive Board of the RTRS, but also
towards new RTRS members and�last not least�its own partners in
the Basel Criteria platform. Sustainability�with or without transgenics?
This author knows
a significant number of European food manufacturers and brand owners
who are by now distinctly confused by the RTRS. Now what�does the
GM-free status they have implemented count as an element of sustainability
or does it not,? Put the question differently: Is the
WWF still the reliable partner of industry members as it has presented
itself for decades? Or is it enabling agribusiness greenwashing?
(Jochen Koester is
the founder of TraceConsult. He can
be reached at [email protected])