Contamination of European food
threatens Canadian export markets
An unapproved variety
of genetically modified flax has been discovered in Canadian exports
shipped to Germany and found growing illegally in the German state of
Baden-Württemberg. The European Commission’s Rapid Alert System for
Food and Feed (RASFF) confirmed the contamination of Canadian flax exports
with the GM flax, devastating Canadian flax sales to Europe. The GM
flax has been illegal to grow in Canada since 2001 when flax growers
forced the government to take the product off the market.
A German company
confirmed the GM contamination in its cereals and bakery products and
said that it could have been distributed on the market. The German surveillance
lab in the state of Baden-Württemberg conducted tests that detected
the GM flax. Officials in Baden-Württemberg discovered large quantities
of GM flax growing illegally in the state, and it has apparently been
unknowingly sold to several EU countries. “We assume that this discovery
will affect not only Germany, but rather all of Europe,” said Peter
Hauk, the state’s agriculture minister.
The GM flax variety,
known as FP967 and “Triffid,” is not authorized for food or feed
use in the European Union. Because it is not authorized in the EU, there
is zero tolerance for FP967 per EU regulations. This means that any
shipment of raw material or flax/linseed derivative that tests positive
for FP967 is not marketable in the EU.
“Absolute
nightmare”
“This is an absolute
nightmare for flax growers and why we worked so hard to have the GM
flax removed,” said Terry Boehm, a flax grower and Vice President
of the National Farmers Union. “Flax growers forced the GM flax off
the market eight years ago to prevent any threat of contamination and
protect our export markets. GM flax was never wanted or needed. We knew
it would destroy our European markets and now we fear this has happened.”
The GM flax is an
herbicide tolerant variety that was developed by the Crop Development
Centre of the University of Saskatchewan. It was named “Triffid”
after a venomous mutant plant from a British science fiction film called
Day of the Triffids. FP967 was approved by Canadian regulators in
1998 but the Flax Council of Canada convinced the Canadian Food Inspection
Agency to remove variety registration for the GM flax in 2001, making
it illegal to grow. Flax growers took this action to protect their export
markets from the threat of GM contamination. In the wake of the 2001
controversy the Centre halted its GM research.
At the beginning
of September, cash bids for flaxseed in Western Canada fell dramatically
based on rumors of GMO contamination. According to a report in Alberta
Farmer, cash bids for flax in Manitoba dropped to as low as $6.78
per bushel after being around $10 per bushel just a few days before
the contamination incident became public.
Barry Hall, president
of the Flax Council of Canada, said the incident could not have come
at a worse time for the Canadian flaxseed industry because flax sales
to Europe begin at this time. Approximately 70%, 500,000 to 700,000
tons, of Canada’s flax is exported to Europe.
Statistics Canada
is currently projecting a 2009-10 Canadian flaxseed crop of 915,000
tons, which is larger than expected and up from the 2008 level of 861,100
tons.
“Industry unable
to control its products”
“This contamination
is extremely shocking as GM flax has not been grown in Canada since
2001,” said Lucy Sharratt, coordinator of the Canadian Biotechnology
Action Network. “Where did this contamination come from?”
The
Flax Council of Canada is working with the Canadian
Grain Commission
to try to figure out how the contamination occurred.
“This is a major
international contamination incident that shows how dangerous any GM
crop field testing and development is for farmers and consumers,”
said Arnold Taylor, an organic flax grower and chair of the Organic
Agriculture Protection Fund of the Saskatchewan Organic Directorate.
“Germany never
approved GM flax but thanks to Canada we are eating illegal and unlicensed
flax in our bread and cereal,” said Stefanie Hundsdorfer from Greenpeace
Germany. “This again proves that once released into nature genetically
engineered constructs are uncontrollable and cannot be recalled.”
Another
contamination incident
The GM flax contamination
is another example of how easy it is for GM crops to contaminate the
food supply—even unapproved varieties grown on a small scale that
haven’t been planted in several years. In 2006, a GM rice variety
developed by Bayer Crop Science called LL601 was found contaminating
commercial long-grain rice supplies shipped to Europe. LL601 was grown
on test plots from 1998 to 2001, but showed up in rice shipments five
years later.
“GM is out of
control, and we clearly need a moratorium on all new GM crops and foods
until we can examine the entire system that regulates GM in Canada,”
said Sharratt.
(Sources: Canadian Biotechnology
Action Network, Alberta Farmer, The Local {Germany})
Copyright
The Organic & Non-GMO Report
October 2009