Due to a lack
of guidance from US National Organic Program (NOP), organic certifiers
have developed their own methods to address GMO challenges posed by non-organic
ingredients. Oregon Tilth Certified Organic and CCOF developed flowcharts
or “decision trees” to evaluate the GM status of ingredients.
Quality Assurance International (QAI) developed a GMO Declaration that it
asks clients to submit to verify the non-GMO status of ingredients.
Oregon Tilth’s decision tree
Oregon Tilth’s decision tree aims to address “the lack of clarity
(in the NOP rules) with regard to how far back you go to evaluate the use
of GMOs,” says Gwendolyn Wyard, Oregon Tilth’s processing program
reviewer.
Wyard developed the decision tree based on similar decision trees
developed by Organic Materials Review Institute (OMRI) for evaluating the
GM status of non-organic inputs used in organic crops, livestock production,
and food processing (www.omri.org/OMRI_GMO_policy.html).
The decision tree asks questions about the GM status of agricultural and
non-agricultural ingredients. Answers to the questions help certifiers
determine the GM status of an ingredient and whether a company’s
GMO statement is acceptable. For example, with non-organic agricultural
ingredients, Oregon Tilth’s decision tree asks, “Is the substance
made using excluded methods (GMO’s) at any step of the production
chain?” A positive
answer means it is prohibited; a negative answer means it is allowed.
In
addition to the decision tree, Oregon Tilth requires a signed Non-organic
Ingredient Declaration or company statement verifying the non-GMO status
of non-organic ingredients.
Create consistency among certifiers
The decision tree aims to clarify complexities of evaluating non-organic
substances for GM content. Wyard says organic processors run into compliance
problems when they submit an affidavit that just says there is no GM DNA
or protein in the final product. “The problem is organic is a process
certification. We’re asking whether they use GMOs, not whether there
is GM DNA or protein in the final product.”
Another aim of Tilth’s
decision tree was to create a more consistent approach among organic certifiers. “We
wanted to get some consistency in addressing the issue and to get on the
same page with other certifiers,” says
Chris Schreiner, Oregon Tilth’s quality control director.
Wyard shared
the decision tree with fellow members of the Western Alliance of Certification
Organizations, which include CCOF, Quality Assurance International, and
Washington State Department of Agriculture. Combined, these organizations
certify the majority of processed organic food in the United States.
CCOF
developed its own GMO decision tree based on information from several sources,
including Tilth’s decision tree, OMRI’s information,
and its own processes, says Brian McElroy, certification services manager.
McElroy says each non-organic ingredient presents unique challenges with
regard to verifying non-GMO status. “There is a lot of case-by-case
handling of things because not all ingredients are the same; each one
comes from a different background,” says McElroy.
Challenge with tocopherols
Verifying the non-GM status of tocopherols/Vitamin E has been particularly
challenging. This is because one or two companies controlled the supply
of Vitamin E, and they collected soybean oil from many commingled sources. “This
is far from having an identity preserved system,” says Wyard.
More
supplies of identity preserved tocopherols are becoming available (see
The Organic & Non-GMO Report, September 2004).
Oregon Tilth requires that tocopherols
come from an identity preserved, non-GM source, but Quality Assurance International
(QAI) does not require an IP tocopherol, says Jessica Walden, QAI technical
specialist.
QAI GMO Declaration
QAI developed a “GMO Declaration” to address questions raised
by the NOP’s rule on genetic engineering. “Because of the lack
of clarification (in the NOP rule), we tried to set up some parameters,” says
Walden.
The declaration describes QAI’s policy toward GMOs focusing
on three categories. With non-organic agricultural ingredients, such as
cornstarch, used in “Organic” and “Made with Organic” categories,
the original organism that produced the ingredient must be non-GM. With
non-organic non-agricultural ingredients, such as flavors and colors, the
product must be free from GM DNA or proteins. Lastly, if microorganisms,
such as citric acid, are used, the microorganism must be non-GM.
On the
declaration, the supplier must highlight measures taken to verify their
non-GMO claim, such as traceability/identity preservation, GMO testing,
and independent audits.
QAI’s GMO declaration has streamlined the
response from suppliers for GMO documentation. Instead of receiving various
GMO statements, QAI has its clients submit the GMO declaration. “We
wanted to get one affidavit to use as a reference,” says Walden.
GMO statements won’t do
Both Wyard and Walden emphasize that submitting GMO-free statements is not
enough. “If someone sends an affidavit saying a product is non-GMO,
we don’t accept it,” says Walden.
“Whenever I get a statement saying an ingredient is GMO-free, I
go back to the client and ask for more information,” says Wyard. This
is because GM material may not be present in the final product, but could
have been used to produce the ingredient.
Some manufacturers state that they
comply with European Union regulations with regard to labeling GM ingredients.
This is also not acceptable, says Wyard, because EU rules do not address
the use of GMOs in processing aids, such as enzymes, which are prohibited
in organics.
Wyard also says many manufacturers won’t sign certifier’s
non-GMO declarations, instead insisting on using their own statements,
such as “while
we can’t be certain…this product is free of DNA or protein
as tested by PCR methods.”
100% verification may not be possible
Organic certifiers want to ensure that GMOs are not used in organic products,
but getting 100 percent verification that all non-organic substances are
non-GMO may not be possible. “If we required 100 percent verification,
we might grind (a processor’s operation) to a halt,” says Wyard.
Still,
organic certifiers must be strict. “The market will respond
to the requirements. The harder we push the more we’ll see companies
that make citric acid develop identity preservation systems (to ensure non-GMO
status),” says Wyard.
Organic certifiers cannot advise their clients
on specific sources for non-GM ingredients, but they can tell them they
are available. “With some
ingredients we know identity preserved sources are out there, and we continually
stress to our clients that they are available,” says Walden.
Organic
certifiers hope to receive further guidance on GMO prohibitions from the
National Organic Standards Board (NOSB). “We try to address
the rule as best as we can, but the ultimate clarification will have to
come from the NOP,” says Wyard.
©Copyright 2006. The Organic & Non-GMO Report.
(April 2006)