(This is the second of a two-part
series)
The Materials Handling
Committee of the US National Organic Standards Board (NOSB) has recommended
that nanotechnology be banned from organic food production. The committee
published a document on the US government�s federal register in September
calling for the ban. The document will be open for public comment, and
then the full NOSB will vote whether to affirm the ban.
Unanimous
support for ban expected
Tracy Miedema, NOSB
member and national sales and marketing manager at Stahlbush Island
Farms, expects the NOSB to unanimously support the ban. �I think the
board will speak with one voice prohibiting nanotechnology,� she says.
If the NOSB votes
for the ban, they would then recommend that the National Organic Program
(NOP) publish a guidance/policy statement prohibiting nanotechnology
in organic food production.
�We will make
a recommendation to the NOP, and we hope they proceed with it to rule-making,�
says Dan Giacomini, NOSB vice chairman and chairman of the Materials
Handling Committee.
Miedema says the
NOSB followed a similar approach in 2007 when it voted unanimously to
ban cloning of animals in organic production, which led to an NOP policy
statement prohibiting cloning.
Miedema was concerned
that products of nanotechnology could achieve status as Generally Recognized
As Safe (GRAS) by the US government, which could allow them to be used
in organics. However, after discussing this with NOP attorneys she was
assured the ban would keep nanotech out of organics. �We tried to
build a document that is airtight,� she says.
Overwhelming majority
opposed to nanotech
In March, the NOSB
asked for public comments about the use of nanotechnology in organics.
According to Giacomini, the comments they received led them to vote
for the ban. �The overwhelming majority of comments said that nanotech
should be banned from the organic industry.�
According to Giacomini,
many comments said that nanotechnology should be considered an �excluded
method� in organics as is genetic engineering.
Two noted experts
argued against the use of nanotechnology in organics. Jim Riddle, organic
outreach coordinator at the University of Minnesota and former NOSB
chairman, wrote that �Nanotechnology will further entrench industrial
agriculture and industrial food as our dominant paradigm, to the detriment
of public health and the environment. As such, nanotechnology is antithetical
to organic principles and should be prohibited from the USDA Organic
standard.� Michael Hanson, senior scientist at Consumers Union, publisher
of Consumer Reports, wrote that there are unknown health and
environmental risks associated with nanoparticles, and that they should
be �excluded as a synthetic or prohibited substance� in organic
production.
Nanotechnology involves
the creation and manipulation of materials at the scale of atoms and
molecules. Scientists are applying nanotechnology to many industries,
including food production. Critics say that too little is known about
the impact of nanoparticles on human health and the environment.
Nanotech
already in organic products
Banning nanotechnology
in organic production presents challenges because it is already being
used in some organic products. Nano Green Sciences, Inc. sells a nano-pesticide
that they claim is �organic,� says Ian Illuminato, health and environmental
campaigner with Friends of the Earth. He also says that other natural
pesticides, such as pyrethrin and copper, could contain nanoparticles
and that nanosilver could be used to clean vegetables of bacteria.
Some personal care
products promoted as organic already contain nanoparticles, Illuminato
says. This is particularly a problem because personal care products
containing organic ingredients are not regulated by the NOP so the ban
on nanotechnology would not apply to these products. However, some manufacturers
may decide to voluntarily eliminate them due to the ban.
Contamination
challenges
Nanotechnology may
present even greater contamination problems to organic foods than genetically
engineered products. �The biggest difference between GMO and nano
is that while GMOs are just in food processing, nano is in both processing
and food packaging,� Giacomini says.
According to Dag
Falck, organic program manager at Nature�s Path Foods, nanotechnology
can impact organic foods, packaging, agriculture, and personal care
products. At the farm level, nanoparticles used in crop inputs, such
as fertilizers or pesticides, could drift through by air or rain to
organic farms. During processing nano contamination of organic could
also occur through nano food processing additives. Organic foods could
be contaminated by nanoparticles used in packaging, utensils, storage,
and transportation and filtration equipment.
Other
organic organizations ban nanotech
The United States
isn�t the first country to ban the use of nanotechnology in organics.
The Soil Association, the main organic certification organization in
the United Kingdom, banned nanoparticles from the organic cosmetics,
foods, and textiles that it certifies. The Biological Farmers of Australia
has proposed that organic certification be applied only to nano-free
products because of the unknown risks of the technology. Austrian organic
certifier Austria Bio Garantie has banned the use of nanoparticles in
cosmetics. The US-based Organic Crop Improvement Association has also
added a clause in their organic standard to regulate the use of nanotechnology.
Copyright
The Organic & Non-GMO Report
October 2009