A new program developed
by Brownseed Genetics, based in Bay City, Wisconsin, with funding support
by Organic Valley Family of Farms, aims to preserve the non-GMO integrity
of organic corn seed. The new program, Purity Plus, was introduced at
the Organic Farming Conference held in LaCrosse, Wisconsin in February.
“Future
of non-GMO corn seed in jeopardy"
Organic corn seed
is increasingly at-risk to GMO contamination because four biotechnology
companies now own the majority of germplasm used to produce foundation
corn seed. There is no labeling requirement for GMO presence in corn
seed. Organic farmers also face increasing contamination problems with
pollen drift from neighboring GM corn fields. “The future source of
non-GMO corn seed is in jeopardy,” says Charlie Brown, president of
Brownseed Genetics.
Brown wanted to
address the problem by developing a seed production system and labeling
standards that would evaluate the “adventitious presence” of genetically
modified traits in corn seed and establish a protocol to preserve the
non-GMO integrity of organic corn seed. He says hybrid seed companies
and farmers don’t know the extent of GMO presence in seed and there
is a “don’t ask, don’t tell” attitude toward the problem.
“We started with
the idea that seed producers and growers have the right to know what
they are planting,” Brown says.
In 2008, Organic
Valley provided a one-year Farmers Advocating for Organics (FAFO) grant
to Brownseed Genetics for the project.
Charlie Brown was
confident he could produce pure, non-GMO corn seed based on his experience
as a seed producer. “I’ve been growing corn seed for farms for 35
years and never had an out-cross (cross-pollination) issue. This gave
me confidence we could do this.”
Brown draws on a
family tradition of corn seed production. Founded in 1911, Brownseed
Genetics is a third generation seed company, and was one of the first
40 seed companies founded in the US. Today, Brownseed uses advanced
molecular assisted breeding techniques to produce new organic seed varieties
with desired characteristics such as early maturity and nutrient enhancement.
“More
pure than we think”
To begin the project,
Brown first needed to determine if there was any adventitious GMO presence
in his seed. He worked with BioDiagnostics, Inc., a seed testing laboratory
in River Falls, Wisconsin, which grew out and tested 50 of Brown’s
inbred corn lines used to produce foundation corn seed. Of those 50,
49 tested negative for any GMO presence.
After completing
his initial investigations, Brown decided there was a need to establish
a new quality standard for organic corn seed. Consequently, he
developed the Purity Plus system to preserve the
non-GMO status from the production of breeder seed to
foundation seed through to the production of commercial hybrid seed.
“We had to determine what protocols would allow for a high degree
of success producing foundation and hybrid seed with no detectable adventitious
GMO presence in a 10,000 or 3,000 seed sample,” he says. “If you
were going to do it right, what would that look like?”
For growing hybrid
corn seed, he established requirements
for minimum isolation distances from other
corn. There are also planting requirements to manage timing of when
corn plants produce silk and pollen. “If we make the effort we can
reduce cross- pollination from GM corn,” Brown says.
Brown conducted
his own test to determine cross pollination. He planted four rows of
blue corn with rows of hybrid yellow corn on each side. As expected,
cross pollination was heaviest in the rows of yellow corn nearest the
blue corn rows. The number of blue corn kernels appearing in the yellow
corn rows decreased the farther from the blue corn rows. At 97 feet
away, there were no blue kernels in the yellow corn. Pollen availability
and timing are also crucial factors to limit
incursion of outside pollen. “From this one data point, and other
published papers on the subject, the science suggests that we may be
more pure than we think. I’m encouraged by that,” Brown says.
A statistical method
for evaluating non-GMO genetic purity was also established. For foundation
corn seed, the label will read “none found in 10,000 seed sample”
which is statistically equivalent to 0.00 – 0.03% at the 95% probability
level. For hybrid corn seed, the label will read “none found
in 3,000 seed sample” which is statistically equivalent to 0.00 –
0.1% at the 95% probability level. There are also standards for
seed quality that address off-type plants, seed purity, color, texture,
and germination.
Third-party
verification
Purity Plus
is designed to be a third-party certification program. Charlie Brown
is now negotiating with the Minnesota Crop Improvement Association and
the Association of Official Seed Certifying Agencies (AOSCA) who would
act as third-party certification agencies and administer the program.
Minnesota and other
state crop improvement associations would also maintain a database of
Purity Plus certified corn hybrids that farmers can access.
Brown is confident
Purity Plus can work based on a successful case study. Pure, non-GMO
foundation corn seed from France was grown to produce hybrids on a 300-acre
farm near Champaign, Illinois. The resulting hybrids tested negative
for adventitious GMO presence.
Brownseed Genetics
intends to offer the Purity Plus program to all corn breeders and hybrid
seed producers in the organic and conventional
industries. Last year, Brownseed Genetics produced three Purity
Plus corn seed lots for a private breeder.
Challenges
Brown acknowledges
challenges facing Purity Plus. The biggest is that while Purity Plus
certified seed is a new program providing seed relatively free of GMOs,
farmers may not be able to avoid pollen drift from neighboring GM corn
fields. This is because organic corn fields tend to be smaller and are
often surrounded by large GM corn fields. Grain buyers may test organic
corn for GMOs and positive tests may lead to rejection of loads from
farmers. Such incidents have already occurred.
Brown says there
needs to be sufficient “pull through” support from the market for
Purity Plus. “There needs to be adequate value for each party of the
value-chain to participate.”
Organic Valley supports
Brown’s work. “Establishing such high standards for organic corn
seed production will go a long way toward protecting the integrity of
the organic movement. We still need to establish the liability of the
biotechnology for GMO contamination but Charlie’s standards will at
least give farmers a clean starting point for production,” says Lowell
Rheinheimer, Organic Valley’s farm resources manager.
For more information
contact Deb Drotos at [email protected] or by phone at 715-594-3355.
(Copyright The Organic & Non-GMO
Report, April 2010)