State legislatures have been known to pander to biotech industry interests. Several years ago, lawmakers in 15 states overwhelmingly passed bills—heavily lobbied for by agribusiness—that would prohibit local control over genetically modified seed. More recently, biotech supporters got the Kansas legislature to pass a bill restricting dairy companies from labeling their products as free of the genetically engineered growth hormone, rBGH. Unfortunately for agribusiness—but fortunately for milk drinkers—Governor Kathleen Sebelius vetoed the bill.
Sustainably Grown?
Recent legislation passed by the North Dakota legislature offers another example. SB 2438, which passed overwhelmingly in both the House and Senate, would allow the state’s conventional farmers who grow GM crops to promote their crops as “Sustainably Grown in North Dakota.”
If Monsanto had written this bill, they couldn’t have done a better job than ND’s lawmakers. Then again, maybe they did write it.
One would think that drafters of a bill on sustainable agriculture would seek out the advice of organizations, such as the Northern Plains Sustainable Agriculture Society, which has focused on sustainable ag for the last 30 years. Didn’t happen.
While there have been attempts to create definitions for “sustainable agriculture,” the ND legislature’s definition lowers the bar considerably. Some requirements listed include “increased efficiencies” “in soil and nutrient preservation,” “in the use of other necessary and measurable agricultural inputs,” and “yield.” These are all fine goals, but they are so general that just about any farmer can meet them.
Most sustainable agriculture standards prohibit the use of GM crops, but this legislation all but makes GMOs a requirement for sustainable agriculture.
Encourages conflicts of interest
The bill establishes an “advisory committee on sustainable agriculture,” whose members include a farmer “who utilizes innovative research-based technologies in farming operations” (i.e. GMO farmer) and “a representative of an international agricultural corporation” (i.e. Monsanto rep).
The bill also says that committee members “may accept gifts, grants, and donations of money, property, and services.” In other words, the bill encourages conflicts of interest.
As expected, North Dakota’s sustainable and organic farmers are appalled. “It is alarming that this bill appears to be more a product of agribusiness than one coming from the groups and individuals who have kept sustainable agriculture alive in this state for so long,” said Lindsey Aull, member of the Missouri Valley Resource Council from Bismarck, ND.
I hope that more states don’t pass such greenwashing legislation as SB 2438. They would render the term “sustainable agriculture” meaningless and undermine the organic label.
© Copyright The Organic & Non-GMO Report June 2009