GMOs
in agricultural inputs pose risks to organic, non-GMO farms
By Dale Monson
With the spread of genetically modified crops and agricultural
products, many agricultural inputs, including organic, are at risk from
GMO contamination. Organic and non-GMO producers need to be aware that
animal feed, seed, and manufactured agricultural products may have been
derived from or mixed with GMOs and must take steps to avoid or minimize
the risk of contamination.
“25% of organic corn is contaminated”
Feed used in organic meat, dairy, and poultry production must be from organic,
non-GM sources, according to the US National Organic Program (NOP). However,
organic feed is at-risk to GMO contamination through commingling in storage
facilities or distribution channels, from contaminated farm machinery,
and through cross-pollination of crops.
The likelihood of GMO contaminated
feed is high because GM corn and soy are widely used as animal feed. Billy
Hunter, an independent organic inspector based in Iowa, says corn is so
highly susceptible to pollen drift that he estimates that “25 percent
or more of organic feed corn available is GMO contaminated—even that
used by the major organic dairy producers—and
about 6% of organic and conventional soybean feed also contains GMOs.”
Mary-Howell
Martens, an organic farmer and feed mill operator supplying three-fourths
of the dairy farms in New York state, says that most of the cross-pollination
of non-GM crops comes from nearby GM fields and, in the case of corn, occurs
in the first 18 rows of the crop. Since NOP standards don’t specify
a barrier between GM and non-GM crops, producers routinely combine the
first few crop rows and treat it as conventional to minimize the effects
of GMO contamination.
Martens says cross-pollination is a real threat to
the integrity of non-GM and organic seed and feed, but sees an even bigger
problem. “Pollen
drift gets all the press, but the biggest risk is planting seed contaminated
through accidental mixing in machinery, particularly hiring custom combining,
which a lot of people do because they can’t afford combines,” she
says. She adds, “Farmers also need to look in their truck boxes and
under their tarps and clean that out.”
GM manufactured inputs
Another GMO challenge for non-GMO and organic farmers is agricultural inputs.
Many fertilizers, inoculants, microbial inputs, biocontrol products, and
supplements may contain GMOs or their derivatives.
Chick Gardiner, California
Organic Fertilizers, Inc. (COFI) says there is a risk of GMO contamination
of fertilizers, since many fertilizers are plant-based and may be derived
from GM corn or soybeans. Even so, he says organic certifiers don’t
consider GMO contaminated fertilizers a risk because GM material breaks
down in the soil and doesn’t pose a threat to organic crops.
Still, Gardiner says COFI makes it a priority to buy non-GM raw materials
for their fertilizers. “We get a letter of guarantee from our suppliers
that there are no GMO products within any of the raw materials that we use.” Gardiner
says he thinks CFOI has been successful in keeping GMOs out of its organic
fertilizers.
As far as GM silage inoculants goes, Hunter says he isn’t
aware of any and thinks no one would use them “because the present
silage inoculants work well and there wouldn’t be any economic advantage
to use GM inoculants.”
Likewise, Martens says there are GM rhizobium
inoculants on the market that aren’t used very much.
Shane Wolf,
director of operations, Advanced Microbial Solutions, says there are GM
microbial soil products available, but AMS avoids the problem by growing
its own product in its labs, strictly from non-GMO sources. Wolf says he
fully expects business to grow on the non-GMO side. “We’re
finding that more and more growers are becoming organically certified or
want to use a more environmentally friendly approach to farming.”
Biocontrol products
GM biocontrol products, which are bacteria and fungi to control plant pests
and disease, can be a problem for the unwary producer. Martens says she
knows of a good biocontrol product that turns on an apple tree’s
defenses against fungus, but the cheapest method the company can find to
produce it is through fermentation of a GM bacterium. Hunter says Bacillus
thuringiensis (Bt) pesticides are allowed in organic agriculture, but farmers
should be aware that there are several GM Bt pesticides sold. There are
also other GM bacterial and fungi products on the market, such as Pseudomonas
fluorescens and Trichoderma viride.
Martens says there are many good probiotics,
which are live bacteria used in agriculture as feed supplements, for sale
that are not GM. She recommends that producers buy probiotics from companies
that are committed to organic production. “Make sure that any products
being used as animal feed come from responsible suppliers that truly know
organic standards and are trying to make products that won’t get
farmers in trouble,” she
says.
Martens adds that organic producers really benefit from working with
a “response,
farmer-friendly certifier who understands the kinds of questions farmers
need answered.”
To control GMOs in inputs, Martens emphasizes that
farmers establish a GMO risk management plan with avoidance strategies. “Look
at the seed supply and find out where it’s coming from. Look at the
pollen drift risk and plan a crop rotation accordingly to avoid planting
next to their neighbor’s Bt corn. Look at the equipment use and risks
and make a plan to reduce them. Then develop a plan on paper for every
single piece (of land), and see the risk and then plan accordingly,” she
says.
Copyright 2006. The Organic & Non-GMO Report.
(May 2006)