EU
split over labeling of GMO contaminated organic food
By Julia Crosfield
European agricultural ministers were divided over appropriate
labeling for organic foods contaminated by GMOs. During a meeting in Brussels
on May 22, some countries requested stricter labeling rules for contaminated
organic products. However, both organic and conventional farmers want priority
given to contamination prevention measures.
“It is a distraction strategy
to suddenly only single out organic,” says
Benedikt Haerlin, Director of Foundation on Future Farming. “All
farmers should have the right not to be contaminated,” he adds.
Biotech-wary
countries—including Belgium, Austria, Italy and Greece—told
the Brussels meeting they want close to zero tolerance of transgenic content
in food labeled organic. However, Commissioner Fischer Boel said forcing
the limit lower for organics would cost farmers too much and would harm
the sale of organic goods.
Current European legislation allows organic
and conventional products to contain up to 0.9 percent GMO content, before
labeling is required, as long as the modified content is accidental or
technically unavoidable. Haerlin says this threshold could be even lower.
He says stringent measures to prevent contamination of fields and conventional
seeds are vital.
According to Haerlin, farmers don’t have to accept
a 0.9% level of contamination from their neighbors. He explains that the
purpose of having a threshold above zero is only to allow for accidental
and technically unavoidable GMO pollution, not to create an “acceptable” level
of contamination.
European organic certification organizations actually
operate a 0.1% threshold of GMO contamination (the lowest detectable level).
However, the largest UK organic certification body, the Soil Association,
is unwilling for the legal labeling level to be set lower than 0.9% without
an EU wide compulsory coexistence regime and a liability framework.
“What
we want are strict regimes to ensure that organic crops are not contaminated
by more than 0.1%,” says Gundula Azeez, policy manager
from the Soil Association. She likens the contamination debate to smoking
and says that passive smoking is prevented by controlling the smoker.
“All
GM farmers should be subject to rules,” Azeez says and, “if
an organic producer loses certification or market contract as a result
of contamination then we need a system where all liable neighbors divide
up compensation.”
The meeting of agriculture ministers concluded that
the Commission will examine whether additional coexistence rules from
Brussels are appropriate. By the end of June it should have evaluated studies
on different liability regimes and guidelines on segregation of conventional
and GM crops.
In addition,
Stavros Dimas, the environment commissioner, is to submit a proposal for
a GM threshold for conventional seeds. Austria’s agriculture
minister, Josef Proll, the current president of the EU agriculture council,
told the meeting the threshold for seeds should be kept as low as possible.
Azeez
says the whole market needs access to GM-free seeds and the GMO contamination
threshold for seeds should be 0.1%. “Seeds are the foundation of
everything.” She
adds, “Countries discussing labeling have the wrong end of the stick.”
© Copyright 2006. The Organic & Non-GMO Report (July 2006).